fbpx

Latest Posts

Home

Facebook

Twitter

Search
About

Lewis Amendment Addresses Met Council’s Flawed Governance Model

On April 24th Rep. Jason Lewis put forth a locally important amendment to H.R. 4, the bill re-authorizing the Federal Aviation Administration. It is a simple amendment that would finally require our unaccountable Metropolitan Council to finally have a majority of its governing board be elected officials.

Lewis’s press release notes:

Our amendment does not seek to change the operations or scope of the Met Council. It does not attempt to change the activities of the board. It simply requires that for a board be in compliance they need to have locally elected official representation consistent with every other MPO in the country.

That the Met Council is obviously flawed as a unrepresentative and locally unaccountable is not even a close call:  while every other of the more than 400 MPOs in the country has a board composed of a majority of elected officials (the legal requirement), the Met Council, by design, does not have even a one such official.

Can this governance issue be easily solved once Lewis’s bill passes? We don’t need to look past Minnesota’s borders, as all seven other MPOs in the state have a board composed of representatives from the counties and cities within the designated urban area (e.g. Duluth-Superior, see page 11, here). Little discussed is the fact that non-urbanized regions of the state are divided into development areas that have governing board with representatives from local counties, cities, schools, and other public interests (e.g. tribal councils). What rationale says such a structure is somehow workable in outside of the Twin Cities, but metro residents can’t be trusted to govern themselves in a democratically accountable way?

As a reminder, this is not Rep. Lewis’s first pushback in the broader battle against the Met Council. In early 2017 we published my report that detailed the Obama administration’s last-minute rule that would have greatly expanded the borders of MPOs, and to merge them over time. In the Chicago region, for instance, we would have seen a single MPO stretching from eastern Indiana, through Chicago, and north of Milwaukee. In Minnesota we might have seen an eventual merger of the Met Council with the planning authority in St. Cloud, which would have created a single MPO from west of St. Cloud, through and expanded Met Council and into western Wisconsin.

Of course, we see one example of why this matters as the Met Council tries to shove billions of dollars into unneeded, unsafe light rail projects that do nothing to alleviate congestion. Would a locally accountably agency be allowed to get away with that? Of course not.

Regardless of where you live in Minnesota, or your political persuasion, you should favour locally accountable and responsive government. Rep. Lewis’s amendment to finally bring the Met Council into compliance with federal law is a great move in the right direction.

Comments

Subscribe

Categories

Upcoming Events

  • Webinar: Say NO to California Car Mandates

    Location: Online

    Sign up for this online webinar HERE! Governor Walz wants to force Minnesota drivers to comply with California’s vehicle regulations. This would make driving in Minnesota more expensive and less safe. Join Center of the American Experiment on January 28th at noon to discuss the California Car Mandates being proposed in Minnesota, and why we should oppose them. Sign up for this online webinar HERE!

    Register Now
  • Exploring Education Options in Rochester

    Location: Online Event

     Sign up HERE! For many students and families, a distance learning model has proved challenging. But there are alternative learning environments that parents are considering and pursuing to better meet the specific needs of their children. Join Catrin Wigfall, policy fellow at Center of the American Experiment, for this free online event to learn about the variety of education options available in Rochester and how giving families choices leads to better educational outcomes. Thursday, January 21 at noon CT Sign up HERE!

    Register Now