Latest Posts





HF 1956: MN Green New Deal Denies Role for Nuclear and Large Hydro

This week, DFL Governor Walz made headlines by announcing his administration would pursue legislation mandating that 100 percent of Minnesota’s electricity come from “Clean Energy” by 2050. Per the usual, the Governor seemed to talk a good game, but there are large and important differences between the way he represented the proposal, and the actual text of the legislation, HF1956, brought forward in the Minnesota House of Representatives.

For example, the Governor and others speaking at the press conference said nuclear would count toward attaining the 100 percent clean energy requirement, but House File 1956, which was introduced by Representative Jamie Long, implies otherwise. Nuclear power is mentioned five times in the forty-page bill. Interestingly, the legislation that is supposed to fight climate change, which the Governor described as an existential threat, does not allow existing nuclear power to count as “carbon free.” 

This means Minnesota’s existing nuclear power plants, Monticello and Prairie Island, which produced 23 percent of Minnesota’s electricity in 2017 wouldn’t be considered “carbon free” on paper.

What’s worse, these two plants generated electricity at a cost of $45 per megawatt hour (mwh), and $37/mwh in 2017, respectively, according to Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) Form 1 data. This easily makes these nuclear plants the lowest-cost source of unsubsidized carbon-free electricity in Minnesota, especially when the additional costs of load balancing, transmission, property taxes, and utility profits are taken into account.

Excluding existing nuclear power from this standard is legislative malpractice against Minnesota families and businesses. Prairie Island is a relatively young nuclear power plant. Its two reactors are only 45 and 46 years old, and they are currently licensed to run for 60 years. The same is true for the Monticello plant, which is 48 years old.

What makes this clause so infuriating is that there are currently six nuclear plants in the United States seeking permission from the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to operate for 80 years. By excluding existing nuclear, lawmakers are giving Xcel Energy zero incentive to keep these reactors online. In fact, it is an excuse to shutter these affordable power plants and build new ones at a massive cost to Minnesota families.

But that’s not what is says in the legislation, and I wish I were making this up.

Really? The authors of this bill don’t think that their decision to exclude existing nuclear power plants from qualifying as “carbon free” would impact the decision to continue operating them? It’s as if the legislators knew this criticism was coming, and they thought they could hide behind this subsection.

Furthermore, this legislation says nothing about lifting Minnesota’s ban new nuclear power plants. One would think that if this legislation were really about saving the planet with carbon-free technology, then this bill would serve to repeal the ban on new nuclear power plants that has been in effect since 1994. That does not appear to be the case here.

The Governor’s lip-service to nuclear power appears to be a bait-and-switch. Nuclear is ok, just not existing nuclear or new nuclear.

Additionally, HF 1956 does not allow for large hydro (hydroelectric dams greater than 100 MW in size) to count, either.

Color me cynical, but if the Governor and legislators are so worried about the impact of climate change in Minnesota, why would they outlaw the two lowest-cost, and reliable options from qualifying as carbon-free electricity? This does not pass the sniff test.

This legislation appears to be a license for monopoly utility companies to print money by padding their rate base by building expensive and unreliable wind and solar, and building battery storage projects. Minnesota should say “No Deal,” to this Green New Disaster.




Upcoming Events

  • Morning in Minnesota: St. Cloud

    Location: St. Cloud

    Sign up HERE! Courtyard by Marriott St. Cloud 404 West Saint Germain Street St. Cloud, MN, 56301 Please join Center of the American Experiment on Tuesday, July 21 for breakfast with Center policy fellow and education expert Catrin Wigfall as she explains K-12 education in the state and its persistent disparities despite decades of increased spending. Following her presentation, Catrin will lead a Q&A session. 7:30 AM Check In and Breakfast 8:00 AM Presentation 9:00 AM Conclude   Catrin Wigfall is a Policy Fellow at Center of the American Experiment. She is also the director of EducatedTeachersMN and EmployeeFreedomMN. Catrin’s…

    Register Now
  • Morning in Minnesota: Marshall

    Location: Marshall Golf Club

      Sign up for this event HERE! Please join Center of the American Experiment on Thursday, July 16 at Marshall Golf Club for a breakfast with Center economist, John Phelan, as he discusses Minnesota’s economic future. Following his presentation, John will lead a Q&A session. 7:30 AM Check In and Breakfast 8:00 AM Presentation 9:00 AM Conclude John Phelan is a graduate of Birkbeck College, University of London, where he earned a BSc in Economics, and of the London School of Economics where he earned an MSc. He worked in finance for ten years before becoming a professional economist. He…

    Register Now
  • 2020 Annual Dinner Featuring Sarah Huckabee Sanders- Now in September!

    Location: Minneapolis Convention Center Ballroom 1301 2nd Ave S Minneapolis, MN 55403

    NEW SEPTEMBER DATE: We have made the difficult decision to once again move the date of this event. We will now host our Annual Dinner on Saturday, September 19th. All tickets bought for the April 4th, or June 18th dates are transferrable. We are so sorry for any inconvenience this has caused, but we look forward to seeing you on September 19! Direct any questions to Kathryn Hinderaker (kathryn.hinderaker@americanexperiment.org or 612-428-7005).   American President: The Unorthodox Approach to Politics that Changed the World. Sarah Huckabee Sanders served as White House Press Secretary for President Donald J. Trump from 2017 to…

    Register Now