Latest Posts

Home

Facebook

Twitter

Search
About

Minnesota Economy No Victory for Dayton

There’s a border battle going on between Minnesota and Wisconsin, a battle between the policies advanced by Gov. Mark Dayton and Gov. Scott Walker.

The two states have long shared similarly sized populations and economies, as well as similar geographies and politics.  But since being elected in 2010, each governor pushed and passed dramatically different policies.  Dayton raised taxes by over $2 billion, increased spending by over 10 percent per person and hiked the minimum wage.  At the same time Walker cut taxes and ended collective bargaining requirements for public employees.  As the Milwaukee Journal Sentinelput it, “Wisconsin is getting its most conservative governance in decades. Minnesota is getting its most liberal governance in decades.”

After taking these divergent paths, people naturally started comparing which path is leading to better economic outcomes and opportunities for the people of each state.

Despite the fact that Dayton’s tax the rich, spendthrift policies have barely been in place for two years, liberals are already claiming victory.

In fact, liberals began claiming victory as early as 2013, well before any Minnesotan filed a tax return under the state’s new fourth-tier tax rate.  Larry Jacobs, a professor at the University of Minnesota Humphrey School of Public Affairs, was one of the first out of the gate with a column in the New York Times.  Though he admitted “firm answers will require more time,” that didn’t stop him from making comparisons and concluding “Minnesota is building a modern progressivism that plows a hopeful path.”

More recently, former Minneapolis Mayor R.T. Rybak penned a Star Tribune column claiming Walker “destroyed [Wisconsin]’s economy,” which was followed by President Obama’s trip to La Crosse, Wisconsin where the President himself declared, “Minnesota’s winning this border battle.”  Liberals simply can’t get enough of comparing Dayton and Walker.  Here’s just a few more outlets declaring Dayton the winner: The American ProspectLaCrosse TribuneMother Jones, and Huffington Post.

Liberal victory speeches touting Minnesota and Gov. Mark Dayton as the shining beacon of progressive policy success to the country simply do not square with two simple economic realities revealed in the graphs below.

First, Minnesota’s economy pulled ahead of Wisconsin’s well before Dayton and Walker took office.  The following graph shows Minnesota’s economy was just a hair smaller than Wisconsin’s in 1997, but began growing larger in 2000.  By 2005, Minnesota’s economy grew to be 6.53 percent larger, which in actual dollars works out to be a $17.5 billion difference.  And since that time, not much has change in relative terms.  In 2013, Minnesota’s economy was 6.43 percent larger and last year it was 6.76 percent larger.  This is consistent with other measures of economic performance, such as per capita personal income or employment, which show Minnesota began improving relative to Wisconsin a long time ago.  These data show whatever lifted the Minnesota economy above Wisconsin must be linked to something that not only predates Dayton and Walker, but even predates Governors Tim Pawlenty and Jim Doyle. And it’s worth noting Minnesota income tax rates went down in 1999 and 2000.

Second, though Minnesota’s economy might beat Wisconsin’s, both states have lost ground to the rest of the country.  The graph below shows Minnesota and Wisconsin GDP as a percent of U.S. GDP.  The slice of the U.S. economic pie declined for both states between 2003 and 2007 and has remained relatively steady since. This strongly suggests neither state has the ideal mix of policies in place to compete for a larger portion of the U.S. economy. Minnesota is therefore no example to the nation of a progressive policy triumph.  Instead, the main takeaway here should be that Minnesota can do better.  How?  A deeper dive into the data reveals lower taxes can help.  More on that next week.

Comments

Subscribe

Categories

Upcoming Events

  • YLC Curling Event

    Location: Chaska Curling Center 3210 Chaska Blvd, Chaska, MN 55318

    Grab your broom and stone and join the Young Leadership Council for an evening of Curling at the Chaska Curling Center! $40 registration includes: Instruction Ice time and equipment Appetizers (Curling Center Bar will be available to purchase drinks) The event will begin with 15-20 minutes of classroom instruction on curling rules and basics followed by 20-30 minutes on the ice for practice and drills. Instructors will be on hand the whole evening to guide your games. Dress Code: Bring a pair of clean-on-the-bottom shoes to change into. No leather soles or metal lace hooks Loose fitting or strechy clothes…

    Register Now
  • The Diversity Delusion

    Location: Hilton Minneapolis 1001 South Marquette Avenue Minneapolis, MN 55403

    Please join Center of the American Experiment on Wednesday, April 24th at the Hilton Hotel for a lunch forum with Heather Mac Donald as she discusses her new book, The Diversity Delusion: How Race and Gender Pandering Corrupt the University and Undermine Our Culture.  Heather Mac Donald is the Thomas W. Smith Fellow at the Manhattan Institute, a contributing editor of City Journal, and a New York Times bestselling author. She is a recipient of the 2005 Bradley Prize. Mac Donald’s work at City Journal has covered a range of topics, including higher education, immigration, policing, homelessness and homeless advocacy, criminal-justice reform, and race…

    Register Now
  • 2019 Annual Dinner Featuring Nigel Farage

    Location: Hilton Minneapolis 1001 South Marquette Avenue Minneapolis, MN 55403

    Purchase Tickets Here

    Register Now