Latest Posts

Home

Facebook

Twitter

Search
About

MN Public Schools Miss the Mark: Test Results Stagnant, Achievement Gap Persists

The Center’s president John Hinderaker recently wrote about the latest student test scores in Minnesota, revealing an all-too-familiar trend of mediocre performance in the state’s public schools.

According to the Minnesota Comprehensive Assessments (MCAs), students’ scores in math and science dropped and reading scores flatlined from 2016 to 2017.

As Hinderaker noted, these results have been typical for more than a decade. And accompanying them is a persistent achievement gap between white and minority scores. White students outscored their minority peers by up to 40 percent in math in 2017.

Source: Minnesota Department of Education, 2017 Minnesota Assessment Results

In reading, minority students’ scores lagged behind their white peers’ scores by up to 36 percent.

Source: Minnesota Department of Education, 2017 Minnesota Assessment Results

Why are achievement disparities among racial and ethnic groups pervasive in the education system? Some would say it’s because less money is spent on minority students—an alleged funding disadvantage. But as I wrote about here, states are throwing large amounts of money into education, and it isn’t resulting in academic improvements. Nor is there evidence increased public spending will close the gaps in student performance.

Take the Minneapolis Public School District. The district spent $17,611 per student. The chart below shows the achievement results of students in grade 11 who took the math assessment and self-identified as Black/African American. Out of 366 students in this category, only 17 showed proficiency.

Source: Minnesota Department of Education, Minnesota Report Card

The Anoka-Hennepin Public School District—the largest school district in the state—spent $12,509 per student, and students in grade 11 who self-identified as Black/African American on the math assessment delivered higher academic results than Minneapolis. Seventy-nine out of 320 showed proficiency.

Source: Minnesota Department of Education, Minnesota Report Card

This isn’t to say Anoka’s test scores are ideal—there are still too many minority students who are not proficient. But the comparison shows more public spending is not the answer to eliminating academic disparities.

If the state truly wants to solve the stubborn achievement gap, it will stop using the same approach over and over again while crossing its fingers for different results.

The results are in, Minnesota. Not all students at public schools are getting the education they need to succeed. Reducing the achievement gap involves introducing competition through school choice. Those stuck in the mediocrity trap deserve access to better educational options and resources.

Students and their parents—not zip codes—should decide where their needs will be best served.

Comments

Subscribe

Categories

Upcoming Events

  • Fall Briefing Featuring Alan Dershowitz

    Location: Ordway Center for the Performing Arts 345 Washington Street, St. Paul, MN 55102

    Please join Center of the American Experiment at the 2018 Fall Briefing featuring Alan M. Dershowitz as he shares his thoughtful analysis of freedom of speech in an era of increasingly divisive and hostile political rhetoric. Dershowitz is one of the nation’s “most distinguished defenders of individual rights.” A graduate of Brooklyn College and Yale Law School, he joined the Harvard Law School faculty at age 25, the youngest in the school’s history, and became an Emeritus professor after 50 years of teaching and 10,000 students. Dershowitz has published more than 1,000 articles and authored 35 fiction and non-fiction works,…

    Register Now