Isaac Orr discusses blackouts on Justice and Drew
I was on Justice and Drew yesterday to discuss the possibility of rolling blackouts in Minnesota. We also briefly chat about annexing parts of Canada. My segment starts around 30…
The story below from the Star Tribune summarizes a meeting held yesterday at the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission (PUC), which was held to determine how well Minnesota’s utility companies weathered the polar vortex that brought bitter-cold temperatures to our state at the end of January.
In short, it was not a good day for Xcel Energy, the largest electricity provider, and the second-largest natural gas provider in the state. The frigid temperatures stressed Xcel’s natural gas system so much they were forced to ask all of their 460,000 natural gas customers to turn their thermostats down to 63 degrees F, “out of an abundance of caution,” as stated by Eric Kirkpatrick, Xcel’s associate vice president of gas operations.
Color me cynical, but I would think if a company wanted to take “an abundance of caution,” they would probably stop trying to build as many wind turbines as possible and would reinforce their natural gas infrastructure.
Speaking of the wind, every single Minnesota utility reported their wind turbines did not show up to work during the polar vortex, either due to low wind speeds, or because it got too cold to operate the turbines safely.
This means wind power is literally unable to show up to work when we need it most. Thank goodness we had coal and nuclear power plants available to provide the electricity we needed to keep our furnaces running. Astonishingly, these coal and nuclear plants are the same coal and nuclear plants many DFL lawmakers want to shut down in order to prioritize more wind power.
The picture below is a slide from Xcel Energy’s presentation. When the cold got goin’, the wind stopped blowin’.
The Strib article is below:
Xcel Energy will “revisit” its planning for extreme cold weather after the utility’s natural gas system proved faulty during January’s big freeze.
The problems led to outages for about 180 customers and prompted nervous Xcel executives to ask all of the company’s 460,000 gas customers in Minnesota to lower their thermostats to 63 degrees to conserve gas supplies.
The problems were discussed at a hearing Thursday called by state utility regulators to review energy providers’ performance from Jan 28 through Feb. 1, when Minnesota faced temperatures of 30 below and beyond.
“Overall, it would appear the state’s utilities [both gas and electric] performed remarkably well, but there were some challenges,” said Dan Lipschultz, vice chairman of the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission (PUC).
Within Xcel’s distribution system, natural gas pressure got so low that in the Princeton area, 152 customers lost gas service for a day, while another 29 in Hugo also lost heat for a shorter time.
Fearing that the low pressure in its system could cause further outages in six surrounding communities, Xcel asked residents there to turn their thermostats down to 63 degrees.
Then, “out of an abundance of caution,” Xcel extended that request to all its Minnesota gas customers, said Eric Kirkpatrick, Xcel’s associate vice president of gas operations.
The low pressure was caused by a record spike in demand. With temperatures dropping to 20 to 30 below, “every house has the furnace going almost all of the time,” Kirkpatrick said. The demand was essentially higher than Minneapolis-based Xcel had planned for in its cold-weather modeling.
“Our system design wasn’t adequate for the loads we actually saw,” Kirkpatrick said. The company will now “revisit the design model for our gas system.”
Xcel, Minnesota’s second largest natural gas provider, will be reinforcing its gas distribution system in areas that lost service during the arctic blast, he said. That means increasing the number of gas lines or swapping smaller pipes for bigger ones.
CenterPoint Energy, Minnesota’s largest gas utility with about 870,000 customers, also saw low pressure in its system, as did other Minnesota gas providers. But none of their customers saw outages.
The PUC also heard from Xcel, the state’s largest electricity provider, on power challenges caused by the freeze, as well as from Duluth-based Minnesota Power and Fergus Falls-based Otter Tail Power. While there were some electricity outages during the deep freeze, problems weren’t of the magnitude of Xcel’s gas shortage.
However, most wind turbines in the state shut down when temperatures sunk to 20 to 25 degrees below zero, utility executives said. The wind turbine issue also was discussed at length Wednesday at a meeting of the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, or MISO, which runs the grid in Minnesota and parts of 15 other states.
When temperatures falls as low as they did in January, wind turbines are programmed to stop so they don’t suffer mechanical damage.