fbpx

Latest Posts

Home

Facebook

Twitter

Search
About

The States Wade into Retirement Security for Private Sector Employees

I am attending a conference this week at State Policy Network (SPN) in the wonderful city of Grand Rapids, Michigan.  During the Q&A on a panel about how to reach Millenials, someone asked the panelists about the nation’s unfunded entitlements and other debt. One man answered, “My generation is screwed. Until the Treasury breaks, Congress is not going to fix the problem. It is going to take a crisis.”

I’d still like to try to avoid that crisis which is why I am looking forward to hearing Senator Tom Coburn on October 13 at Orchestra Hall for our 2015 Fall Briefing. (Quick plug: do you have your tickets?)

In addition to describing the enormity of the obligations sitting squarely on the shoulders of our citizenry, Coburn will offer some concrete ideas about what we can do to responsibly clean up the mess before the next generation of taxpayers comes of age. Maybe we can change their opinion about us and our form of government before it is too late.

As anyone who has climbed out of a financial hole knows, the first thing you do is stop taking on debt. Next, you get your spending lined up with your income and obligations, hopefully including debt repayment.

It is with these basic rules in mind that I bring to your attention a new development on the horizon at the state level. It is the latest “progressive” idea sweeping the nation. And it has the full support of the Obama administration. Minnesota and other states are thinking about, or in a few cases enacted, a new retirement program for people who work in the private sector but are not eligible for a retirement plan.

As reported in the Wall Street Journal, Oregon followed California and Illinois in creating a new program that automatically deposits money in state managed accounts. These three states have an “opt out” approach with an automatic withdrawal of three percent (3%). That means the state has decided for these people that their paycheck is going down 3% unless they go through some bureaucratic process to “opt out.” And they have added to the burden employers face when processing payroll. The details vary as to what size employer must comply.

Minnesota flirted with the idea a few years ago, and decided to study the proposal with an eye toward enactment when the study was done. It was part of a slick package deal being touted under the “Women’s Economic Security Act.” If the Minnesota House had not flipped in 2014, I think it would be law today.

Of course all Americans should be saving for a secure retirement, and stop thinking that Social Security is a retirement plan. Soon enough, Americans will get reacquainted with savings and thrift because they will not have a choice. But creating an intrusive, opt-out program that gives 3% of lower income workers’ paychecks to the government, especially debtor states like Illinois and California, cannot turn out well.

Aside from the obvious objections to the state stepping as big brother for private sector employees, the cynic in me worries about these new assets being used to prop up underfunded public pension plans. As I have told you many times, Minnesota’s debt exceeds $17 billion. The story is much worse in Illinois and California.

I also worry that this modest program is just a foot in the door for creating taxpayer guaranteed government pensions for private citizens and making us more dependent rather than less dependent on government. Many people in the private sector are not eligible for a 401k so the potential revenue for the state is quite large.

Today, the state takes 3% of paychecks, tomorrow the state guarantees a certain return on that deposit, and probably a hedge against inflation, no matter how much is actually in the account. Just like a public pension.

The irony about this program is that state wants to overcome a lack of retirement savings and security for people in the private sector by adding to the nation’s already burdened fiscal status.

Wouldn’t it make more sense to focus on reducing the cost of doing business for employers so they can pay employees more, and offering even more generous tax incentives to save for retirement, so Americans will save more?

Comments

Subscribe

Categories

Upcoming Events

  • Morning in Minnesota Breakfast Series: Winona

    Location: Signatures Restaurant, 22852 County Road 17, Winona, MN 55987

    Please join Center of the American Experiment Friday, March 6 at Signatures for a FREE breakfast with economist John Phelan.

    Register Now
  • Lunch Forum with Amity Shlaes

    Location: Hyatt Regency Minneapolis 1300 Nicollet Mall Minneapolis, MN 55403

    Buy tickets HERE. About This Event: Enjoy our Early Bird Ticket Special through February 23rd! After this date, ticket price will increase to $30. Doors open at 11:30 AM, program and lunch begin at Noon. In Great Society, the New York Times bestselling author of The Forgotten Man and Coolidgeoffers a stunning revision of our last great period of idealism, the 1960s, with burning relevance for our contemporary challenges. Today, a battle rages in our country. Many Americans are attracted to socialism and economic redistribution while opponents of those ideas argue for purer capitalism. In the 1960s, Americans sought the…

    Register Now
  • 2020 Annual Dinner Featuring Sarah Huckabee Sanders

    Location: Minneapolis Convention Center Ballroom 1301 2nd Ave S Minneapolis, MN 55403

    American President: The Unorthodox Approach to Politics that Changed the World. Sarah Huckabee Sanders served as White House Press Secretary for President Donald J. Trump from 2017 to 2019. A trusted confidant of the President, Sanders advised him on everything from press and communications strategy to personnel and policy. For two and a half years, Sanders was at the President’s side, battling with the media, working with lawmakers and CEOs, and staffing the President on every foreign trip, including dozens of meetings with foreign leaders. Sanders is only the third woman and the first mother to hold the job of…

    Register Now