fbpx

Latest Posts

Home

Facebook

Twitter

Search
About

The Star Tribune’s ‘fake news’ on transit

The Star Tribune recently carried an editorial critical of our new report ‘Twin Cities Traffic Congestion: It’s No Accident‘.

The editorial board wrote that “Peer-reviewed academic research…has found that expanding freeways does not reduce congestion, but transit does”. The paper they cite for this claim is ‘The fundamental law of road congestion: Evidence from US cities’ by economists Gilles Duranton and Matthew A. Turner. However, the Star Tribune’s presentation of it is a complete distortion.

Hang on a second…

Here is what Duranton and Turner actually say about transit in their paper;

“We conclude that an increased provision of roads or public transit is unlikely to relieve congestion” (Abstract)

“Unfortunately, there is currently little empirical basis for accepting or rejecting the claims of…the American Public Transit Association that without new investment in public transit, highways will become so congested that they “will no longer work”. (Page 1)

“For public transit as measured by the count of large buses in an (Metropolitan Statistical Area), the conclusion is the same as in panel A: the provision of buses does not affect total (Vehicle Kilometers Traveled) in the MSA” (Page 27)

“The resulting elasticity estimates of these two tables also support the conclusion that public transit does not affect traffic levels

Finally, we note that the finding that public transit does not reduce traffic levels should be of independent interest to policy makers. ” (Page 28)

“Not only do we provide direct evidence for this law, but also show find evidence that three implications of this law; near flat demand curve for VKT, convergence of traffic levels, and no effect of public transit on traffic levels” (Page 42)

“Importantly, our data provide little evidence that extensions of public transit will reduce traffic” (Also page 42)

“Second, we note that this research eliminates both capacity expansions and extensions to public transit as policies to combat traffic congestion” (Page 43)

It is hard to see how they could have been any clearer on this point. Yet the Star Tribune has them saying the exact opposite.

Did the Star Tribune editorial board actually read the article they cited? If not, why did they cite it? If they did, why did they misrepresent it so dishonestly?

Transport is one of the most important issues facing the Twin Cities. We need a debate. But that debate needs to be open and honest, and not riddled with these sorts of ‘alternative facts’.

Comments

Subscribe

Categories

Upcoming Events

  • Morning in Minnesota: Red Wing

    Location: St. James Hotel 406 Main StreetRed Wing, MN 55066

    Please join Center of the American Experiment on Tuesday, December 17th at the St. James Hotel for a free breakfast with Center policy fellow and education expert, Catrin Wigfall as she explains the Center’s “Great Jobs Without a Four-Year Degree” project.

    Register Now
  • NEW DATE: Nov. 25th Twin Cities Reception with Andrew C. McCarthy

    Location: Metropolitan Ballroom & Clubroom5418 Wayzata Boulevard, Golden Valley, MN, 55416

    Please join Center of the American Experiment and National Review Institute for a reception with Andrew C. McCarthy, a former top federal prosecutor, a senior fellow at National Review Institute, a contributing editor at National Review, a Fox News contributor, and a well-known commentator on legal, national security, and political affairs. His new book, Ball of Collusion, is a story about what happens when those we trust to be the guardians of our system anoint themselves the masters of our system. For our own good, of course. As for collusion, that word we’ve heard so incessantly from pundits and leaky…

    Register Now
  • NEW DATE: Nov. 25th Rochester Lunch Forum with Andrew C. McCarthy

    Location: Hilton Rochester Mayo Clinic Area10 East Center Street, Rochester, MN, 55904

    Please join Center of the American Experiment and National Review Institute for lunch with Andrew C. McCarthy, a former top federal prosecutor, a senior fellow at National Review Institute, a contributing editor at National Review, a Fox News contributor, and a well-known commentator on legal, national security, and political affairs. His new book, Ball of Collusion, is a story about what happens when those we trust to be the guardians of our system anoint themselves the masters of our system. For our own good, of course. As for collusion, that word we’ve heard so incessantly from pundits and leaky government…

    Register Now